Can You Have Too Many Tools?

Published by

on

At what point do the tools in the toolbox become a blocker to progress and how to stop it before it slows your business down.

Define Tools

The Merriam-Webster definition of tool covers a large scope from a “handheld device that aids in accomplishing a task” to “a means to an end”. For now, let’s just think about a tool as any item, method, or process that fixes a problem or improves a situation.

If you have a toolbox at home (or even a junk drawer in the kitchen), you have tools. Some tools are very specific in function; others can have multiple purposes and multiple applications. A power drill is only for drilling holes but a butter knife can have a range of functions from spreading (it’s main function) or cutting to prying open a lid (where’s my screwdriver?) to eating peas from a plate when a spoon (another tool) is not available.

Image Credit: stocksy.com “Kitchen Cabinet Junk Drawer At Home”

Tools in the Workplace

Likewise in our businesses, we have tools available to get our jobs done and to solve problems. We can choose from a multitude of platforms (e.g tools) that exist for emailing, team collaboration, documentation, spreadsheeting and analysis, presentations, project management, software development, etc. It’s seemingly endless. To make matters worse, many of these same platforms are cross-functional, meaning they can be used effectively for more than one function, or purpose.

Think butter knife!

One tool – multiple functions and applications. Do you use a butter knife or a screwdriver to pry open that jar?

New tools and the latest innovations are seductive. Sometimes they are necessary. Knowing how to identify the difference early can help your business from falling into the trap of “shiny object syndrome”, getting blocked by it, and seeing your operational efficiencies fall to the floor.

1. Tool overlap is when multiple tools do the same job.

This can lead to loss of momentum caused by your employees hesitating to complete tasks and having to switch context between tools needed for those tasks.

Get Unblocked by creating a “one job, one tool” rule, set up a standard operating procedure (“SOP”), and communicate to all team members that do those tasks.

2. Each tool comes with invisible costs.

These costs ordinarily include training, licensing, permissions, integrations, and troubleshooting. The new power tool you picked up a few weeks ago is cool, but that thing needs special batteries, maintenance, and extra storage space. Ideally, these costs are covered when the tool boosts your business instead of blocks it.

Get Unblocked by executing a quarterly tool audit. List each tool/application/platform, its cost, and how much time it is saving the business or what benefits it provides.

3. Fragmented workflows occur when tasks live across too many platforms.

Here, any employee task becomes a scavenger hunt, particularly in the absence of standard operating procedures. The team spends more time navigating tools instead of completing the work. This breaks momentum and contributes to extended completion and delivery time.

Like at home. You’re hanging a picture, have the hammer in one hand but you’re searching through the junk drawer for the right nail.

Get Unblocked by mapping the ideal end-to-end workflows for each task, identifying where the tools interrupt the workflow. Consolidate the steps to cover fewer tools or automate the handoffs so the work flows more effortlessly.

4. Decision paralysis occurs when a choice has to be made between tools.

This is illustrated by delayed starts to a task, stalled projects, or unclear ownership.

Get Unblocked by setting in place default behaviors, like SOPs. By establishing these and communicating them clearly, you will eliminate hesitation and free up mental energy for the actual work.

5. Tool adoption fatigue drains both enthusiasm and trust.

The most effective way to put a blocker into any business is to change tools too frequently. It is exhausting for any team because each new tool requires a pivot to the unknown, sometimes away from a process that was working well: learning curves, defining new workflows, and rebuilding trust. Downstream, this can result in various problems, including quality problems in customer service, slow onboarding with longer learning curves, reduced accountability, and inconsistent processes across teams.

All of these are blockers!

Get Unblocked by test driving new tools in a pilot program first. Determine what the expected benefits are and then measure the results of the pilot. If the results of the pilot do not meet the expected benefits, don’t implement it.

Quick Questions: Is Your Toolset a Blocker?

Do you have multiple platforms for the same function?

Does the tool require more updates, training, or troubleshooting than the value it provides?

Are you or your team hunting across multiple platforms to find information?

Are people unsure which tool to use and hesitate before beginning work?

Are people rolling their eyes when “another platform” is announced?

Final Reflections

Just like the drawer in your kitchen or the toolbox in your garage, your business tools should make work easier, smoother, and faster. Tools are meant to be boosters – extensions of your capability – not blockers that slow you down, confuse your team, or multiply your workload.

The real skill isn’t collecting tools.

The real skill is having the right tools, knowing which ones to use, when to use them, and when to put the rest back in the box.